Seashell from Amboise
Embossed galvanized steel cornice featuring a repetitive seashell motif, manufactured by Mesker Brothers Iron Works. Cornice design no. 221 (1910/$0.50 per foot) at 20 E. Depot Street in Chesterfield, Illinois. Blind balustrade above and vine pattern below are panels separate from the cornice.
Abstracted and stylized floral designs and patterns dominated the design vocabulary of both Mesker companies, and American architectural ornamentation during the Victorian period in general. Nonetheless, a few aquatic-related ornaments also found their way onto Mesker fronts, as was the case with the “dolphin panel.” Another such motif was a seashell.
Like the dolphin, the seashell can be traced to one of the printed plates from American architectural publications which Bernard Mesker collected and annotated with possible ideas for galvanized sheet-metal ornamentation. The specific drawing appeared in the July 30, 1887 issue of the Building magazine and was identified as a “cornice from an old house, Amboise, September 17, 1886” (this is the date of the drawing, not the building). Obviously Bernard agreed that the seashell made a handsome cornice ornament as indicated by his note. In the late 1890s the motif was introduced in two versions and appeared on several embossed galvanized sheet-metal cornice designs that the Mesker Brothers produced.
The original French ornament was likely carved into stone; the Mesker version is also a negative impression in contrast to their typical positive embossing that appears in relief. They also mimicked the motif’s repetition across the cornice designs, though this was their standard modus operandi. Regardless, both of the initial variants were not exact reproductions of the Amboise seashell. Rather, they were simplified versions that in the process of adaptation lost much of the French stonework’s delicate quality. It was not until a slightly later third iteration from the turn of the twentieth century that the Amboise original was replicated more faithfully. And the price for this European derived sophistication? As low as $0.30 per cornice foot.
There’s another, perhaps accidental, similarity between the dolphin and seashell motifs. Amboise is in France and was once the home of the French royal court. Did Bernard consciously select this design based on its origin (as he may have done with the dolphin due to its heraldic connotations), as a nod to St. Louis’s heritage or is this merely a coincidence? Almost certainly the latter, but fun to consider nonetheless.
Page of French travel sketches from the July 30, 1887, issue of the Building magazine, in the collection of Bernard Mesker. Image courtesy of David Mesker.
Close up of a cornice rendering from Amboise, France, with Bernard Mesker’s handwritten note pointing to the seashell motif. Image courtesy of David Mesker.
Comparison of the Amboise seashell and the third and final iteration of a Mesker Brothers embossed design.
One of the earlier (late 1890s) seashell motifs by Mesker Brothers Iron Works, with slightly more attenuated proportions. Cornice design no. 234 (1910/$0.40 per foot) in Nevada City, California. Image courtesy of Arthur Hart.
Another rendition of the seashell, with a simpler and bolder execution. Cornice design no. 226 (1910/$0.40 per foot) at 119 S. Washington Street in Westfield, Illinois.
Page from a 1910 Mesker Brothers catalog depicting several cornice designs incorporating the seashell motif. The seashell on this page most closely resembles the drawing from Amboise.
Another catalog page of cornices with seashells. These are the earlier, less faithful reproductions of the original inspiration.
Comments
One Response to “Seashell from Amboise”Trackbacks
Check out what others are saying...[…] least speculate about, the origins of some of the Mesker Brothers motifs including the fish panels, sea shells, and clusters of columns, largely because of the evidence for such inspiration left behind by […]